The fall of Big Figgy

Reports Revealed

Bryan Littlely

Senior Journalist

Email
Last updated:
Melina Capogreco and Douglas Shire Council arborist Robert Scomazzon discuss the status of the fig tree before the works to remove it began. Picture: Bryan Littlely

Douglas Shire Council made its decision to remove the Rex Smeal Park fig tree over safety concerns within a few hours of being given the formal recommendation by its lead arborist Robert Scomazzon.

Evidence provided to the Supreme Court of Brisbane in the withdrawn matter of Melina Capogreco vs Douglas Shire Council - lodged on October 20 in a bid to halt the tree removal - shows the report and its recommendation to remove the tree was provided on Friday, October 16.

Council issued its release to announce the tree removal that afternoon, with Councillor Damian Meadows speaking to the decision being a "tough call".

A collection of arborist reports were provided to the Supreme Court as Council's defense in the matter, with Mr Scommazon listed as the DSC witness, providing affidavits under oath to the Court on October 27.

The documents are considered "public information" by the Supreme Court and were provided to Newsport by a citizen who independently applied for them when Mrs Capogreco withdrew her action on November 3, triggering the removal of the tree by council using contractors MPDT.

The reports and mentions within them include a September 21, 2026, assessment by Jim Scott from Central Tree Services in Mossman who wrote: "Given the tree’s species characteristics and the nature of identified fungal decay, there are no feasible options for safe retention of this tree if the area surrounding the tree is to remain accessible to the public and adjacent high target infrastructure is to remain in place,”

James Cook University expert Pieter Taylor inspected the tree on September 25 and reported that Big Figgy could “remain retainable in the short term through targeted canopy reductions’’.

“This is an important conflicting opinion and should be noted,” Mr Scomazzon said. “However, it remains a preliminary ground-based view and is not presently supported by identification of the limbs to be reduced or removed; nominated pruning points and the required extent of load reduction; total volume of canopy removal needed; a nominated retention period.”

A summary of the assessments by MPDT arborist James Watts compiled on October 1, coincided with a site visit between Mr Scomazzon and Total Tree Solutions' Jack Lewandrowski where a limited inspection was done before a quote was provided for the removal of the tree.

Details of the cost are not revealed in the documents.

"Possible pruning options were discussed,” Mr Scomazzon wrote in the report.

“Jack verbally indicated that removal was likely to be the most appropriate option. He provided a quotation for tree removal involving the use of a crane due to the tree being considered unsafe to climb.”

Mr Scomazzon's report from his final visual assessment of the tree, conducted on October 1 made the recommendation: “I do not consider continued retention above the playground, walkway, seating, and event areas reasonable given the current evidence and advice.

“Council should progress towards removal of the mature Ficus at Rex Smeal Park.”

As reported by Newsport on Friday, November 13, MPDT's arborist James Watts warned council in April 2025 that the construction of the playground and playground rubber surfacing since his previous inspection had added significant stress to the tree and was not to Australian standards.

That detail was not highlighted to the court in Mr Scomazzon's statement as council's witness in the case.

Douglas Shire Council has an open opportunity to speak to the issue.

Latest News